Just War Doctrine, and what it means. « Conservative Libertarian Outpost
Archive for the ‘Politics’ Category
Just War Doctrine, and what it means.
August 25, 2007I was in a Yahoo Chat room, and a young woman was on a rant. Nothing new about that, but her subject was war. War is inherently evil was her premise. Further, anyone that ever engages in war is evil, at least that is her hypothesis. I happen to believe a bit differently. I questioned her about her beliefs and while I believe that she is, or was sincere; She is horribly misinformed. It has been some time since I studied ethics in college, and high minded Kantian philosophy has to step aside in favor of Utilitarianism when someone is pointing a weapon at you or your loved ones.
That being said, the earliest documentation of the idea that war can or cannot be justified that I am aware of is found in the writings of the Roman Catholic Church. From that we find the following;
The Catechism of the Catholic Church, in paragraphs 2302-2317, authoritatively teaches what constitutes the just defense of a nation against an aggressor. Called the Just War Doctrine, it was first enunciated by St. Augustine of Hippo (354-430 AD). Over the centuries it was taught by Doctors of the Church, such as St. Thomas Aquinas, and formally embraced by the Magisterium, which has also adapted it to the situation of modern warfare. The following explanation of Just War Doctrine follows the schema given in the Catechism.
At we find further discussion.
Just-war theory deals with the justification of how and why wars are fought. The justification can be either theoretical or historical. The theoretical aspect is concerned with ethically justifying war and forms of warfare. The historical aspect, or the “just war tradition” deals with the historical body of rules or agreements applied (or at least existing) in various wars across the ages. For instance international agreements such as the Geneva and Hague conventions are historical rules aimed at limiting certain kinds of warfare. It is the role of ethics to examine these institutional agreements for their philosophical coherence as well as to inquire into whether aspects of the conventions ought to be changed.
As I said at the beginning. I believe differently than that young lady. I believe that war cannot only be justified but that it is in fact mandatory under certain conditions. I do not believe, as do so many of my fellow Libertarians, that all war needs to be reactive, that is, after the fact (of having been attacked.) Preemptive war can be justified in many cases; It is called being “quicker on the trigger.” Now, before all the Christians jump all over me about the commandment “Thou shall not kill.” Go find a Diaglot, a word for word translation, and read the actual commandment; “Thou shall not commit murder” is what it says.
So young pacifist lady, sleep well, because rude men stand guard protecting you.
War, what is it good for..?
August 25, 2007I was looking through the wordpress categories this morning, and there seemed to be a theme. One even asked “War what is it good for?”
One thing that I am sure of, is that the people that hate war the most, are those that have fought in them. That being said, each has also said that it was something that had to be done. It has removed tyrants from oppressing people. King George, and Saddam Hussein come to mind. It has relieved the world of totalitarians bent on destruction or the imposition of their political or religious beliefs. Ever hear of a guy called Adolf Hitler?
Certainly war should be a last resort in all but a few select cases, but it is not at all the evil boggy man that so many these days want to cast it as. It removes the evil more often than not. At least in final battles. The by products of war are also something to think about. Advances in medicine and meteorology come to mind.
So, for those of you that claim that war has no value, I will paint a historical picture; Enjoy your gruel as you watch your daughter being raped by the descendent’s of Genghis Khan, you have faith that Allah will rescue you, a faith that was forced upon you…
Global Warming, Global Cooling…
August 18, 2007Source: Patriot Post
Yet more about this new religion that is being force fed to us by those that know what is better for us than we ourselves do. What a farce! When, in all of history, or even beyond, has the Earth not been either warming or cooling?
Most of the evidence concerning U.S. temperature trends is collected by NOAA’s National Climatic Data Center, which gathers information from about 1,200 weather observation stations across the nation. These stations are small wooden sheds with thermometers, which are read at intervals, mostly by volunteers. Many are located in sprawling urban and industrial centers, known as “heat islands,” and are subject to higher readings than stations in rural areas where temperatures are subject mostly to “land use effects.”
Most of the recent global-warming alarmists use 1998 as the benchmark for the hottest year on record, but it turns out that their reporting is flawed, the result of a math blunder.
In fact, 1934 was the hottest year on record, and four of the ten hottest years in the U.S. were recorded in the 1930s. The second hottest year on record was 1998, but the third hottest was 1921, not 2006. Notably, six of the ten hottest years occurred prior to 90 percent of the economic growth associated with increased greenhouse-gas emissions.
H. Sterling Burnett, a senior fellow at the National Center for Policy Analysis, reports, “Much of the current global-warming fear has been driven by [NASA scientist James] Hansen’s pronouncements, and he routinely claims to have been censored by the Bush administration for his views on warming. Now that NASA, without fanfare, has cleaned up his mess, Hansen has been silent—I guess we can chalk this up to self-censorship.”
New climate reports
In the winter of 2007, NASA satellites indicated that water temperatures in the Gulf of Alaska were dropping, suggesting that cooling Pacific waters may be a precursor to the reversal of a 30-year warming trend. The cooling resulted in the coldest season of Arctic air the lower 48 have seen in more than three decades.
Additionally, Reuters “News” Service reports, “Australian scientists have discovered a giant underwater current that is one of the last missing links of a system that connects the world’s oceans and helps govern global climate. New research shows that a current sweeping past Australia’s southern island of Tasmania toward the South Atlantic is a previously undetected part of the world climate system’s engine-room.”
This, of course, raises an all-important question: How can the climate debate be “settled” if we still don’t know what we don’t know?
Climate modeling
The computer models cited by Albert Gore and company are outcome-based, depending on how a programmer varies some of the five million input parameters or the multitude of negative and positive feedbacks in the program.
Scott Armstrong is a professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School and one of the world’s foremost experts on long-range forecasting. He is author of “Long-Range Forecasting,” the most frequently cited book on forecasting methodology.
Armstrong and Kesten Green of New Zealand’s Monash University examined the IPCC’s report, and, at the 27th Annual International Symposium on Forecasting, they concluded, “Claims that the Earth will get warmer have no more credence than saying that it will get colder.”
Armstrong bet Gore $10,000 that he couldprovide a better climate forecast than that of the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which Gore cites regularly. “The methodology was so poor that I thought a bet based on complete ignorance of the climate could do better,” said Armstrong. “We call it ‘the naive model’.” Gore’s office replied, “Please understand that Mr. Gore is not taking on any new projects at this time.”
The warming Solar System
As it turns out, there are some other planets in our solar system which are experiencing global warming—and these planets don’t have SUVs.
Mars is getting hotter. NASA scientist Lori Fenton reports that the Red Planet has warmed by around one-half degree Celsius in the last three decades, which likely contributes to the retreat of Mars’s southern polar ice cap.
According to Habibullo Abdussamatov, director of space research at St. Petersburg’s Pulkovo Astronomical Observatory in Russia, “The long-term increase in solar irradiance is heating both Earth and Mars. Man-made greenhouse warming has made a small contribution to the warming seen on Earth in recent years, but it cannot compete with the increase in solar irradiance.”
On Neptune, MIT researchers say that planet’s largest moon, Triton, has heated up significantly since 1989, when the Voyager space probe sent back readings from the planet. Astronomer James Elliot and colleagues from MIT, Lowell Observatory and Williams College report, “At least since 1989, Triton has been undergoing a period of global warming. Percentage-wise, it’s a very large increase.”
Imke de Pater and Philip Marcus of the University of California, Berkeley, report that Jupiter is growing a new red spot. “The storm is growing in altitude,” de Pater says, which indicates a temperature increase in that region. The researchers think that, near term, the temperature on Jupiter may increase six degrees Celsius in large areas.
University of Hawaii astronomer David Tholen and his colleagues report that even though Pluto was closer to the Sun in 1989, they are not surprised by a warming that began this year. “It takes time for materials to warm up and cool off, which is why the hottest part of the day on Earth is usually around 2 or 3 p.m. rather than local noon,” Tholen said. “This warming trend on Pluto could easily last for another 13 years.” They predict Pluto’s temperature will rise two degrees Celsius before its next cooling trend.
The Climate Inquisitors
If you are a scientist, politician or journalist, and refuse to comport with Albert Gore’s eco-theological orthodoxy, you’d best put on some body armor.
Speaking to Al Gore’s minions during “Live Earth: The Concerts for a Climate in Crisis,” Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., said of political leaders who suggest global warming is not predominantly manmade, “This is treason and we need to start treating them as traitors.” Junior added, “Get rid of all those rotten politicians we have in Washington, DC.” We presume his bloated uncle is excluded?
The University of Oregon’s George Taylor is that state’s official climatologist, but Gov. Ted Kulongoski wants to strip Taylor of that title because his skepticism about CO2 as a primary factor in global warming interferes with Oregon’s goals to reduce CO2.
Elsewhere, the Weather Channel’s Dr. Heidi Cullen is demanding decertification of weather reporters who dare question global-warming orthodoxy.
Academicians who express their skepticism about global-warming causes are at high risk of losing research grants. Conversely, those who advocate for CO2 causation are in line for some big-money handouts. Thus, when academicians say “green,” they aren’t necessarily referring to the environment.
“Journalist” David Roberts is setting his sights on the “denial industry,” proclaiming, “When we’ve finally gotten serious about global warming, when the impacts are really hitting us and we’re in a full worldwide scramble to minimize the damage, we should have war crimes trials for these bastards [read: ‘skeptics’]—some sort of climate Nuremberg.”
Nonetheless, some of the most ardent global alarmists are starting to change their tune. In 2005, Chris Mooney wrote “The Republican War on Science,” a thorough indictment of the GOP’s attempt to discredit scientific work on climate change. When he started research for his latest book, “Storm World: Hurricanes, Politics, and the Battle over Global Warming,” he assumed it would be more of the same. Then, after meeting with leading climatologists, he concluded, “There’s a wide range of respectable positions here. In the end, I had to write a completely different book.”
Quote of the week
“The world meat industry produces 18 percent of the world’s greenhouse-gas emissions, more than transportation produces. A gallon of Ben & Jerry’s ice cream requires electricity guzzling refrigeration, and four gallons of milk produced by cows that simultaneously produce eight gallons of manure and flatulence with eight gallons of methane. The cows do this while consuming lots of grain and hay, which are cultivated by using tractor fuel, chemical fertilizers, herbicides and insecticides, and transported by fuel-consuming trains and trucks.” —George Will
Winners and losers in the game of life.
August 17, 2007Every year I try to keep up with some of the absurd things that people do in this world that we live in. Well, this year there is something for everyone, from Texas Fred to Chris Smith, to Bear.
I’ve met some of these.
These people prove it is a terminal condition. As always, competition this year has been keen.
The candidates this year are…
Eighth Place
In Detroit, a 41-year-old man got stuck and drowned in two feet of water after squeezing head first through an 18-
inch-wide sewer grate to retrieve his car keys.
Seventh Place
A 49-year-old San Francisco stockbroker, who “totally zoned when he ran,” accidentally jogged off a 100-foot high
cliff on his daily run
Sixth Place
While at the beach, Daniel Jones, 21, dug an 8 foot hole for protection from the wind and had been sitting in a
beach chair at the bottom when it collapsed, burying him beneath 5 feet of sand. People on the beach used their
hands and shovels trying to get him out but could not reach him. It took rescue workers using heavy equipment
almost an hour to free him.
Jones was pronounced dead at a hospital.
Fifth Place
Santiago Alvarado, 24, was killed as he fell through the ceiling of a bicycle shop he was burglarizing. Death was
caused when the long flashlight he had placed in his mouth to keep his hands free rammed into the base of his
skull as he hit the floor.
Fourth Place
Sylvester Briddell, Jr., 26, was killed as he won a bet with friends who said he would not put a revolver loaded
with four bullets into his mouth and pull the trigger.
Third Place
After stepping around a marked police patrol car parked at the front door, a man walked into H&J Leather &Firearms
intent on robbing the store. The shop was full of customers and a uniformed officer was standing at the counter.
Upon seeing the officer, the would-be robber announced a hold-up, and fired a few wild shots from a target pistol.
The officer and a clerk promptly returned fire, and several customers also drew their guns and fired. The robber
was pronounced dead at the scene by Paramedics. Crime scene investigators located 47 expended cartridge cases in
the shop. The subsequent autopsy revealed 23 gunshot wounds. Ballistics identified rounds from 7 different
weapons. No one else was hurt.
HONORABLE MENTION
Paul Stiller, 47, and his wife Bonnie were bored just driving around at 2 A.M. so they lit a quarter stick of
dynamite to toss out the window to see what would happen. Apparently they failed to notice the window was closed.
RUNNER UP
Kerry Bingham had been drinking with several friends when one of them said they knew a person who had bungee-
jumped from a local bridge in the middle of traffic. The conversation grew more heated and at least 10 men trooped
along the walkway of the bridge at 4:30 AM. Upon arrival at the midpoint of the bridge they discovered that no one
had brought a bungee rope. Bingham, who had continued drinking, volunteered and pointed out that a coil of
lineman’s cable lay near by. They secured one end around Bingham’s leg and the tied the other to the bridge. His
fall lasted 40 feet before the cable tightened and tore his foot off at the ankle.
He miraculously survived his fall into the icy water and was rescued by two nearby fishermen. Bingham’s foot was
never located.
AND THE WINNER IS…
Zookeeper Friedrich Riesfe ldt (Paderborn, Germany) fed his constipated elephant 22 doses of animal laxative and
more than a bushel of berries, figs and prunes before the plugged-up pachyderm finally got relief. Investigators
say ill-fated Friedrich, 46, was attempting to give the ailing elephant an olive oil enema when the relieved beast
unloaded. The sheer force of the elephant’s unexpected defecation knocked Mr. Riesfeldt to the ground where he
struck his head on a rock as the elephant continued to evacuate 200 pounds of dung on top of him. It seems to be
just one of those freak accidents that proves… “Shit happens”
Since things appear so quiet… « Conservative Libertarian Outpost
August 15, 2007Since things appear so quiet…
August 15, 2007
The blogs appear to be very quiet today so I suppose that something needs to be done to stir things up a bit. The blogosphere thrives on controversy, or at least so it appears. A few well chosen key words might just spice things up! 🙂
- The Drug War: Making thugs into millionaires!
- Gun Control: Hitting the intended target each time, every time!
- Politics: Warfare by another name, and just as deadly in the long run.
- Education: Never assume that letters following a name have the least bit to do with intelligence. ( Unknown Professor at UCSD circa 1969)
- The Democrat Party: A Communist plot!
That should get things going today! Enjoy!
A few bad apples
August 5, 2007http://texasfred.net/archives/404/trackback/
This story goes back aways in the blogosphere. Bottom line being that don’t do the crime if you can’t do the time.
A lot of people caught serious flak at the time that the story broke. People on both sides. So be it. I myself, have said time and time again that we need to let the system work. Allow it to do it’s job so to speak.
The Hate America First Brigade is having a field day pointing out the Soldiers and Marines that have been convicted of this or that crime in Iraq.
Well? I hate to piss in your Cheerios but these are such a small minority of our armed forces that they are statistical insignificant.
An “Ugly American.” Maj. Scott H. Southworth
August 5, 2007
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Law of the land..?
August 5, 2007This week, a House Foreign Affairs subcommittee attempted to investigate whether the Mexican government was involved in the prosecution of former U.S. Border Patrol agents Ignacio Ramos and Jose Alonso Compean, who were sentenced to prison for shooting drug smuggler Osvaldo Aldrete-Davila in the buttocks. The panel’s attempts were mitigated when Justice Department and Homeland Security officials declined to appear for the hearing. State Department official Charles Shapiro did appear and testified that there was no documentation to indicate that Mexico influenced the Ramos-Compean prosecution.
However, under grilling from Rep. Dana Rohrabacher (R-CA), Shapiro admitted that the State Department would not know whether Mexico had contacted other U.S. departments regarding the matter. Shapiro stated he was unaware of previous communication that occurred between U.S. Attorney John Sutton’s office and the Mexican government in other border matters, including the similar case of Texas Sheriff’s Deputy Guillermo Hernandez, in which Mexican officials wrote letters to Sutton’s office requesting prosecution.
The panel plans to hold another hearing and call on Sutton and his staff to testify in the matter. If you have not already done so, please join the nearly 64,000 Patriots who have already signed our petition, Free the Texas Three and Secure Our Borders.
SOURCE: PATRIOT POST
Alright, as any that read my posts here as well as elsewhere, I am very much against making thugs into millionaires. Also known as “The Drug War.” This bovine feces of tossing our sworn Law Enforcement Officers into prison for doing precisely what the hell we pay them to do is ridiculous.
The truly larger issue here though is the law that was applied, as in mandatory sentencing for so-called “gun crimes.” I warned that this would happen. I warned the NRA. I warned the POA, and I sounded the alarm through letters to the editor that were published. This is the kind of crap that happens when you use the United States Constitution as toilet paper.
Figure it out folks; Ex Post Facto Law, the taking of Inalienable Rights for less than felonies, sexist law enforcement based upon political correctness are all immoral.







